Part A
You are a legislator with a perfect record for voting on constitutional statutes. You have been presented with two proposed
statutes. Read each one, and then read the case, analyzing a replica statute for constitutionality. Decide whether you should vote for
or against the proposed statute if you want to keep your perfect record. Links to the cases are on 12.4.2
.
1. The proposed statute is Disorderly Conduct and reads as follows: It is a misdemeanor to engage in indecent or disorderly conduct in the presence of another in a public place. This statute was analyzed for constitutionality by Satterfield v. State, 395 S.E. 2d 816 (1990). The case is available on 12.4.2. Should you vote for or against the statute?
2. The proposed statute is Gang Violence and Juvenile Crime Prevention Act and reads as follows: State Prosecutors are hereby authorized to bring specified crime charges against minors fourteen and older in the criminal division of adult court rather than in the juvenile division without a judicial determination that the minor is unfit for a juvenile court disposition. This statute was analyzed for constitutionality by Manduley v. Superior Court, 41 P.3d 3 (2002). The case is available on page 12.4.2
Should you vote for or against the statute?
Part B
The “Five-Minute University” Reflection
Overview
Congratulations on reaching the final week of the semester! As we prepare for the Final Exam—which covers Barkan Chapters 1–16 and 18, all weekly slides, and course videos—we are going to wrap up our discussions with a classic, classic perspective on college learning.
Please watch this famous, short Saturday Night Live clip from 1980:
Father Guido Sarducci’s Five Minute UniversityLinks to an external site.
In the video, Father Guido Sarducci proposes a fast-track university where you only learn what the average college graduate actually remembers five years after graduation (for example, in Economics, you only learn “supply and demand”).
Using his premise as a lens, start a thread and answer these three questions in your own words:
- How will you see things differently as a result of what you have learned about crime, criminals, and the justice system this semester?
- What will you remember from this Criminology course in five years? (What is your personal “supply and demand” takeaway?)
- If you only had five minutes to teach someone about criminology and the causes of crime, what would you tell them?
Logistics & Expectations
- Writing Quality:Â Keep up the great work you’ve shown all semester. Write in clear, thoughtful, and complete sentences.
- Â
Â
